In his new book Disbelief: The Origins of Atheism in a Religious Species, Will Gervais, PhD., a global leader in the psychological study of atheism, shows that the ubiquity of religious belief and the peculiarities of atheism are connected pieces in the puzzle of human nature. Does God exist? This straightforward question has spawned endless debate, ranging from apologists’ supposed proofs of God’s existence to New Atheist manifestos declaring belief in God a harmful delusion.
It’s undeniable that religion is a core tenet of human nature. It is also true that our overwhelmingly religious species is also as atheistic as it’s ever been. Yet, no scientific understanding of religion is complete without accounting for those who actively do not believe. In this refreshing and revelatory book, Gervais argues that religion is not an evolutionary puzzle so much as two evolutionary puzzles that can only be solved together. First is the Puzzle of Faith: the puzzle of how Homo sapiens – and Homo sapiens alone – came to be a religious species. Second is the Puzzle of Atheism: how disbelief in gods can exist within our uniquely religious species. The result is a radically cohesive theory of both faith and atheism, showing how we became a uniquely religious species, and why many are now abandoning their belief.
Through a firsthand account of breakthroughs in the scientific study of atheism, including key findings from cognitive science, cultural evolution, and evolutionary psychology, Disbelief forces a rethinking of the prevailing theories of religion and reminds both believers and atheists of the shared psychologies that set them on their distinct religious trajectories. In casual prose and with compelling examples, Gervais explains how we became religious, why we’re leaving faith behind, and how we can get along with others across the religious divides we’ve culturally evolved.
Will Gervais, PhD, is a cultural evolutionary psychologist and has been a global leader in the scientific study of atheism for over a decade. Dr. Gervais’s research has been featured in media such as The New York Times, the Washington Post, National Public Radio, Der Speigel, Psychology Today, Vox, and Scientific American. His interdisciplinary work, lying at the intersection of cultural evolution, evolutionary psychology, and cognitive science, has garnered international scientific recognition. He was named a Rising Star by the Association for Psychological Science and is the recipient of the Margaret Gorman Early Career Award from the American Psychological Association and the SAGE Young Scholar Award from the Foundation for Personality and Social Psychology.
Gervais and Shermer discuss:
- What is religion?
- Theism, Atheism, Agnosticism, Deism, Pantheism, etc. defined
- How many atheists and agnostics and religious skeptics are there really?
- Atheism and morality, trust, politics, etc.
- Why are atheists so unpopular?
- Metaphysical atheism vs. epistemological atheism (or agnosticism)
- Popular nonanswers for religion and belief in God(s) (the Puzzle of Faith)
- Role(s) of religion in history and society today
- Is religion and belief in God(s) adaptive or a byproduct?
- What cognitive features of the brain are engaged in faith, religion, & belief in God?
- Patternicity, Agenticity, Sensed presence effect, essentialism, dualism, theory of mind, teleology
- Big Gods vs. animism, polytheism, supernaturalism
- Folk physics (pre-Newtonian) and biology (creationism)
- Why some religions are so much more successful than others
- Group selection vs. cultural selection
- Is religion good for society?
- Is religion good for personal health and happiness?
- When we colonize Mars will far future humans on other planets believe in God?
- Does religion need to be replaced with something?
- Enlightenment Humanism, Secular Humanism, and other alternatives.
If you enjoy the podcast, please show your support by making a $5 or $10 monthly donation.
This episode was released on September 3, 2024.
